How to Go About Getting an Antique Jewelry Appraisal

Oval American shell cameo brooch, about 1900, showing a draped classical figure

Jewelry is appraised for several reasons, such as insurance, resale, estate settlement or simple curiosity. Antique pieces add complications: age, workmanship, replaced stones and earlier repairs can all change the description and the figure. This guide covers how to approach an antique jewelry appraisal. Values vary, and any number should be treated as an estimate tied to a purpose and a date.

What a good appraisal should contain

GIA recommends getting an unbiased appraisal from an experienced jeweler or an independent jewelry appraiser. In its guide to antique and vintage rings, GIA says the appraisal should give a full description of the piece, including condition, validate its historical period and estimate its value. Ask what type of value the report will state. Replacement value for insurance is generally a different figure from what a piece might sell for, and the amount originally paid is not a reliable guide to either.

Choosing the appraiser

The American Society of Appraisers (ASA) consumer FAQ points out that appraisers fall into different disciplines, including gems and jewelry, so look for one who works in that field. Directories are available from the American Society of Appraisers (ASA) consumer FAQ, the Appraisers Association of America and the International Society of Appraisers. Questions worth asking include:

  • What education and professional designations do you hold, and how were they earned?
  • Do you have experience with antique pieces of this period and type?
  • Will the report comply with USPAP, and what will it include?
  • What is the fee, how is it calculated, and when will the report be delivered?

The ASA advises against using an appraiser who offers to purchase what they appraise or who charges a percentage of the item’s value. Both arrangements create a conflict of interest.

Do not assume the stones are natural or original

GIA cautions that antique and vintage jewelry may contain synthetic gems or simulants, and that fine stones in some pieces have been removed and replaced with imitations over the years. Synthetic rubies, for example, have been made since the late 1800s. Its estate jewelry guidance also recommends looking for dents, deep scratches, missing stones and signs of repair, such as unlikely solder joints. An appraiser can identify these features. For significant diamonds or gemstones, GIA suggests asking for a report from an independent laboratory.

Preparing for the appointment

  • Photograph the piece from several angles, including any hallmarks, maker’s marks or inscriptions. Marks differ by country and period, and an appraiser can help interpret them.
  • Collect receipts, family documents, old photographs or boxes that show history.
  • Avoid aggressive cleaning or repairs beforehand, since they can change the condition the appraiser needs to record.
  • Keep each piece separate so stones and metal do not scratch one another.

GIA notes that a jeweler’s loupe (a 10-power magnifier) is a common tool for checking a piece. Some owners also use a clip-on phone microscope to photograph small marks for their records, for example the 30X LED phone microscope from nichestuff.shop. A magnifier is a supplement only and does not replace an expert examination.

Costs, timing and records

Fees and timelines depend on the appraiser and the number and complexity of pieces. The ASA says a credible valuation of gems and jewelry can take several weeks, and that appraisal agreements should define the scope of work and delivery date. Keep the finished report, with photographs, in a safe place separate from the jewelry itself, and give your insurer a copy if the report was prepared for coverage.

Photo: “Cameo (USA), ca. 1900 (CH 18443241).jpg,” Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Catalog photograph of a shell cameo brooch; it is not a piece offered for sale here.

We run the NicheStuff store; some links in this post go to products we sell.


Discover more from Antique Stuff

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.