The safest thing we can do for old silver is often the least dramatic: keep it clean, dry, and off the polishing wheel. Every time tarnish is removed, a little metal goes with it. That is why museum conservators treat polishing as something to do sparingly, not as a weekly ritual, and why folk recipes that promise a bright shine — lemon juice, toothpaste, baking soda pastes, or long soaks in a chemical dip — can do more harm than good. This guide follows the Canadian Conservation Institute’s note on the care of silver (CCI Notes 9/7) and its instructions for a precipitated calcium carbonate polish (CCI Notes 9/11), and it points to the Institute’s separate advice on coins and medals (CCI Notes 9/4). It replaces earlier wording on this page that suggested lemon juice and a toothbrush on coins.
Decide whether it should be cleaned at all
The CCI advises examining a piece before any tarnish is removed. We need to know whether it is a silver alloy, such as sterling (92.5 percent silver, in the usual British and American standard), or a plated object with only a thin silver layer over a base metal. Marks help: a lion passant and other hallmarks can indicate a sterling standard, while letters such as E.P.N.S. or the words “silver plate” indicate electroplate. The Institute notes that electroplating as a commercial process dates from a patent in 1840. If the plating is already worn through, further polishing will take more of it off.
We should also look for gilding, inlay, solder joins, hollow handles or feet, and non-metal parts such as ivory, bone, wood, or felt. The CCI says objects with hollow sections or mixed materials should not be immersed, and that polishes will damage gilding. Decorative recesses were sometimes meant to stay darker; a dip that strips tarnish out of every engraved line can leave a piece looking scoured.
Handling, washing, and tarnish removal
Wear clean cotton gloves, or handle by surfaces that will be covered. Skin salts mark silver. For ordinary dust and grease, the CCI recommends washing or swabbing with a mild detergent in distilled water, keeping wooden or organic parts dry, then rinsing in distilled water and drying thoroughly with a soft cloth or warm air. Light tarnish sometimes comes off at this stage, and no abrasive is needed.
If tarnish remains and we have already decided the object can stand a polish, the CCI describes a homemade polish of precipitated calcium carbonate — a very fine, chosen grade of chalk, not household scouring powder — mixed to a paste and used gently, then rinsed and dried. Commercial silver polishes vary; anything coarse, or any product used as if more rubbing were always better, is a risk to hallmarks and to plate. Chemical dips can be appropriate in some conservation settings, but the CCI warns that they over-clean engraved or chased surfaces if used carelessly, and they are not a soak to leave overnight. Electrochemical methods belong to a conservator, not to a kitchen sink.
Coins, medals, and what not to use
Collectible coins and medals should not be cleaned as if they were spoons. The CCI treats them as a separate problem and refers readers to its coins note; collectors and dealers generally regard amateur cleaning as damaging, because it can scratch, strip toning, and reduce, rather than increase, interest in a coin. Lemon juice, ketchup, toothpaste, baking soda, and a toothbrush are all a bad idea here. If a coin might have numismatic value, leave it alone and ask a specialist. For coin types discussed elsewhere on this site, see Morgan silver dollars.
The same caution applies to other folk recipes. Acidic foods and abrasive pastes can etch, scratch, or leave a dull surface. A toothbrush is too harsh for most hallmarks and for plated highlights. If a piece is important, gilded, heavily damaged, or simply puzzling, stop and consult a conservator; our page on finding an expert in antique restoration is a starting point.
Storage is better than another polish
Because each cleaning removes metal, the CCI emphasises prevention: dry storage, tarnish-inhibiting cloths or papers sold for that purpose, and cases that are not a source of sulphur. Wool, rubber bands, some paints, and felt that was not chosen for silver can all encourage tarnish. Air-tight plastic is not automatically safe if the object is put away damp or if the plastic itself off-gasses; the object should be dry, and materials should be inert. Do not wrap silver in newspaper or ordinary wool and forget it.
Checklist
- Identify first: sterling or another alloy versus silver plate, and any gilding, hollow parts, or organic handles.
- Handle with clean gloves and avoid fingerprints.
- Wash, rinse, and dry with distilled water and a mild detergent before any polish.
- Polish sparingly with a very fine conservation-grade paste such as precipitated calcium carbonate; do not scour hallmarks.
- Do not clean collectible coins with lemon juice, toothpaste, dips, or a brush.
- Store dry in materials meant for silver, and polish less often rather than more.
Hallmarks and maker’s marks are part of the identification of a piece, not decoration to be brightened. The CCI’s polishing advice is deliberately mild because the edges of a punch are easy to wear down. On plate, the high points of a design are usually the first to show a warmer base-metal colour; that is information, and further polish will widen it. If we are unsure whether a piece is plate or a solid alloy, we should not invent a test with a file or a drop of acid. A marks reference, a magnet only as a very rough clue in some plated bases, and, when it matters, a professional opinion are safer than a scratch.
The teapot in the photograph is a 1773 silver example by Paul Revere in the Worcester Art Museum. It is a museum object, not a piece offered for sale here.
Top image: “Teapot, 1773, Paul Revere silver collection, Worcester Art Museum – IMG 7635” by Daderot, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
Discover more from Antique Stuff
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
