Antique Dishes — Victorian Majolica: Coloured Glazes, Makers and How to Tell It from Maiolica

“Majolica” is used in two different ways, and mixing them up is the usual source of confusion. One meaning is the older Italian tin-glazed earthenware usually spelled maiolica. The other, which is what most English-speaking collectors mean today, is the brightly coloured lead-glazed earthenware that factories such as Mintons showed in the mid-nineteenth century. This guide is about that Victorian and later coloured-glaze ware. It draws on Wikipedia’s articles on Victorian majolica, maiolica, Mintons and Palissy ware, and it sits beside our live page on antique oyster plates, some of which were also made in majolica.

Maiolica and majolica are not the same thing

Italian maiolica is earthenware covered with an opaque tin glaze and then painted. Victorian majolica, as Wikipedia describes it, is earthenware whose decoration comes mainly from coloured lead glazes laid over a relief-moulded body, so that leaves, shells, animals and rustic grounds keep their modelling under a glossy, often saturated colour. The two traditions are historically connected — Mintons deliberately looked back at Renaissance and Palissy models — but they look and feel different in the hand.

Mintons exhibited this coloured-glaze ware at the Great Exhibition of 1851, and other English factories followed, including Wedgwood, George Jones, and Holdcroft. American and continental factories made related wares. Because the word was fashionable, it was later applied loosely to almost any brightly glazed earthenware, which is why a careful description of the glaze and the modelling matters more than the word on a label.

What Victorian majolica usually looks like

Naturalistic leaf dishes, baskets, oyster plates, jardinieres, pitchers and figure groups are typical. Oak leaves, vine leaves, corn, cauliflower and shell forms were popular because the coloured glaze could pool in the veins and recesses and run thinner on the high points. That pooling is one of the things we look for: a sharp moulded vein under a translucent colour is more convincing than a flat, painted leaf on a smooth surface.

The back or underside may show a factory mark, a shape number, or an impressed name. Unmarked pieces are common. A mark helps only when it matches the body, the glaze quality, and a documented shape. Later reproductions, some of them still being made, often have softer detail, heavier or muddier colour, and marks that imitate famous names.

Condition and later problems

Lead-glazed earthenware chips, crazes and stains. Hairlines along rims and handles are frequent, and hidden cracks can run through the well of a dish. Because the glaze is part of the decoration, a large reglaze or a painted-out chip changes the object more than a similar repair would on a plain white plate. We should look at handles, spout tips, basket rims and any applied flowers or fruit, which are the first parts to break.

Staining through a crackle can look like dirt and may not come out. That is not always a reason to reject a piece, but it should be reflected in any description. If a repair is suspected, a strong light and, where it is safe to do so, an ultraviolet lamp can help; a professional opinion is better than a guess, and our page on finding an antique restoration expert explains when to call one.

Checklist

  • Type: coloured lead glazes over relief-moulded earthenware, not a tin-glazed painted maiolica plate unless that is what is actually being sold.
  • Modelling: crisp veins, shells or leaves, with glaze pooling in the recesses.
  • Marks: factory names and shape numbers checked against the form, not taken on their own.
  • Condition: chips, hairlines, staining and restored tips or handles.
  • Reproductions: softer moulds, odd colours, and marks that copy well-known factories.

Makers, American wares, and living with the glaze

Besides Mintons and Wedgwood, English factories such as George Jones and Holdcroft are frequently cited by collectors of naturalistic coloured-glaze ware. In the United States, the Phoenixville, Pennsylvania, firm often known as Griffin, Smith & Hill made a related ware sold under the Etruscan name. Continental factories, including Belgian and French firms, produced their own coloured-glaze table and decorative wares in the same decades. A leaf dish or a rustic jug can therefore be English, American, or European, and the glaze quality and the mark, when there is one, matter more than an assumed origin.

Palissy ware, as Wikipedia describes it, is a still older French tradition of rustic ceramics with high-relief shells, fish, and plants, which nineteenth-century factories consciously revived. Some Victorian majolica is Palissy-like; some is simply a cabbage or a basket with a bright green glaze. Using both words carefully — “Palissy-style relief” versus “coloured-glaze majolica” — keeps a listing honest.

Because the colour is the glaze, we should not put these pieces in a dishwasher or scour the recesses to make them “even.” A dry or slightly damp soft cloth is enough for dust. A stain in the crackle of a used dish may be permanent. If a handle has been reattached, look at the tightness of the joint and at any change in gloss around the repair. A well-documented shape in a museum collection or a specialist mark book is a better comparison than a single photograph of a similar leaf.

The plate in the photograph is a coloured-glaze example of about 1880 marked for Boch Frères, in a grapes-and-vine-leaves pattern. It is a collector photograph of a period continental piece, used here to show the kind of naturalistic glazed relief typical of the ware, not as a plate for sale.

Top image: “Boch Freres Kermis Plate, coloured glazes, c. 1880, grapes and vine leaves pattern” by Davidmadelena, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.


Discover more from Antique Stuff

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.