The Morgan dollar is a large United States silver dollar struck from 1878 to 1904 and again in 1921, named for its designer, Mint engraver George T. Morgan. Many millions were made, but prices vary with the date, the mint and the condition. The history here draws on Wikipedia, and the collecting advice on the American Numismatic Association (ANA) FAQ.

Where the coin came from
In 1873 Congress ended the free coinage of silver, and the Seated Liberty dollar went out of production. Lobbying by mining interests to restore the free coinage of silver led to the Bland–Allison Act, which became law over President Rutherford B. Hayes’s veto on February 28, 1878. It required the Treasury to buy between two and four million dollars’ worth of silver each month and have it coined into silver dollars.
Morgan was found for the Mint through the Royal Mint in London and arrived in Philadelphia in 1876. For Liberty he used Anna Willess Williams of Philadelphia as his model, and the reverse shows an eagle with outstretched wings. Production began on March 11, 1878, and the design was soon revised to reduce the relief and give the eagle seven tail feathers instead of eight.
Production stopped in 1904 when the silver bullion bought under the Sherman Silver Purchase Act ran out. In 1918 the Pittman Act authorized melting up to 350 million silver dollars; the Treasury eventually melted 270,232,722, most of them sold to the United Kingdom. The act also authorized replacement coins, so Morgan dollars were struck once more in 1921, the only year Denver made them. The Peace dollar replaced the design later that year.
The basics of the coin
- Composition: 90% silver and 10% copper, about 0.7734 troy ounce of pure silver per coin.
- Weight and size: 26.73 grams and 38.1 millimeters across, with a reeded edge.
- Mint marks: none for Philadelphia, CC for Carson City, S for San Francisco, O for New Orleans and D for Denver (1921 only). The mark, if there is one, sits on the reverse just above the word “Dollar.”
The silver content sets a floor under the price that moves with the silver market; collector value sits on top.
What affects collector value
The ANA says collector value depends largely on rarity, which is set by mintage, and on condition, along with how many collectors want the coin. The Morgan series shows how far mintages differ. The 1893-S, with 100,000 struck, is the series’ key date and the lowest mintage of any Morgan dollar. By contrast, more than 44 million were made at Philadelphia in 1921.
Carson City coins, marked CC, are only about 2% of all Morgans and tend to carry a premium. After previously unknown bags turned up in Treasury vaults, slightly more than 2.8 million Carson City dollars were held back, and the General Services Administration sold them in seven mail-bid sales between 1972 and 1980. Wikipedia cites a PCGS CoinFacts estimate that fewer than 10% of Morgan dollars struck still survive, a result of the Pittman Act melting.
The ANA describes a practical definition of an uncirculated coin as one with no trace of wear, in the same condition as when it left the Mint, though nicks or scratches from other coins in a Mint bag are possible. A circulated coin has visible wear, usually first on the highest points of the portrait and eagle. The ANA adds that a coin altered for jewelry, with a hole punched or soldered to a chain, has a significantly reduced value.
Check the date and the coin itself
The US Mint began striking Morgan dollars again in 2021 as collectibles, in 0.999 fine silver rather than the original 90% alloy, so a modern piece needs a close look at the date. Copies are also common. The ANA notes that many “tribute” copies were made as facsimiles and are usually marked “Copy” or “Replica,” while copies made to deceive can be hard to detect. It advises taking a coin that matters to an ANA-affiliated dealer for authentication.
Cleaning and storage
The ANA’s answer on cleaning coins is a firm no. A cleaned coin is bright but still worn, experienced collectors can usually spot it, and it loses some value. For a coin so corroded that it is unrecognizable, the ANA says a solution of mild dish soap and distilled water may be tried, followed by a thorough rinse in distilled water and air drying or gentle patting; otherwise it recommends leaving cleaning to a professional conservation service.
For storage, the ANA recommends keeping coins individually in containers that limit exposure to damaging elements, such as acid-free envelopes or mylar flips that are free of PVC, in a dry place with a fairly constant temperature. Flips containing PVC can break down over time under heat and light and release hydrochloric acid, which appears as a greenish slime that can cause irreparable damage to a coin’s surface.
Getting a coin valued
The ANA does not buy, sell or value coins. It points owners to R. S. Yeoman’s A Guide Book of United States Coins for an approximate retail range, and to an ANA member dealer for a physical examination, the only way to establish an exact value. A dealer buying coins must make a wholesale offer, so the price paid will be below retail.
Top image: “Morgansilverdollar 1882circulated” by Aquinassixthway, CC0 1.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Discover more from Antique Stuff
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One comment
Comments are closed.