An antique appraisal is a professional opinion of what an object is worth, written for a stated purpose. An informal opinion from a dealer, a friend or an online forum can be useful for curiosity, but it is not the same thing. This guide explains the difference, how to find a qualified appraiser, and what to prepare. Values vary with the market, the date and the purpose of the appraisal, so treat any figure as an estimate.
Know which kind of value you need
The American Society of Appraisers (ASA) consumer FAQ notes that a report should clearly state the kind of value being determined. Common types include fair market value (used for taxes), replacement value (used for insurance coverage) and liquidation value (used when property must be sold quickly). The same object can carry quite different figures under each definition, so tell the appraiser why you need the report before work begins.
Informal opinions versus written appraisals
- Verbal opinions from dealers or shops. These are often offered with the hope of buying or consigning the piece. They can help you gauge interest, but they are not a documented valuation.
- Online forums, apps and auction-house estimates. Photo-based estimates can point you toward a maker or period. Auction houses generally evaluate items they might sell, so the estimate reflects that purpose.
- Written appraisal reports. A report describes the object, explains the method used and states the type of value. This is the document insurers, courts and tax authorities typically expect.
How to find a qualified appraiser
Professional organizations publish directories of members who have completed training and agreed to a code of ethics. Options include the Appraisers Association of America, the American Society of Appraisers (ASA) consumer FAQ and the International Society of Appraisers. Many appraisers follow the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), which is maintained by The Appraisal Foundation. The ASA suggests asking about education, designations, references, relevant experience with your type of object, and whether the report will be USPAP-compliant.
The ASA also lists warning signs. Avoid an appraiser who offers to buy what they appraise, who charges a percentage of the item’s value, or who has an undisclosed interest in the value of the item.
What to gather before the appointment
- Clear photographs from several angles, including any marks, labels, signatures or damage
- Measurements and a note of materials, if known
- Receipts, family records, old photographs or other provenance documents
- A list of any repairs, refinishing or replaced parts you know about
Condition, restoration, maker, rarity, provenance and current demand all influence value. Missing or uncertain information does not rule out an appraisal, but it may limit how firmly the appraiser can describe the piece.
Costs and timing
According to the ASA, fees are set by the individual appraiser and are often hourly, half-day or full-day. Research time may be billed, and the cost of a credible valuation of personal property or jewelry varies; it can take several weeks. Ask for a fee schedule or estimate and a written scope of work, including the delivery date, before you sign an agreement.
When tax rules apply
If you plan to donate valuable property and claim a deduction, the IRS requires documentation that depends on the value. IRS Publication 561 explains when a qualified appraisal is needed and who may act as a qualified appraiser. Check the current rules or speak with a tax professional before commissioning a report for that purpose.
A practical order of steps
Start by deciding why you need the value, then research comparable sales and the maker if marks are present, then contact two or three credentialed appraisers who handle your category. Compare their qualifications, fees and report formats rather than choosing on price alone.
Photo: “Teapot MET DP258808.jpg,” American silver teapot by Tiffany & Co., The Metropolitan Museum of Art, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons. A museum object, not an item for sale on this site. Used here as an example of an object someone might have appraised.
Discover more from Antique Stuff
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

9 comments
Comments are closed.