Antique American pocket watches range from precision railroad watches to inexpensive mass-market models. The terms used in listings are not always accurate, so it helps to know what collectors mean by each one. This guide draws on the National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors (NAWCC) encyclopedia and conservation advice from the Canadian Conservation Institute.
Railroad watches
Many people call any large, old pocket watch, especially one with a locomotive engraved on the case, a railroad watch. The NAWCC’s encyclopedia entry on railroad watches says this usage is frequently incorrect. The term refers to the high-grade watches that met railroad time-service standards, which the railroads themselves called “standard watches.”
Those standards were not uniform. The NAWCC explains that each railroad’s time service department defined which watches it would accept, and requirements changed from decade to decade. Its working definition is that a standard watch is one that met the general time-service requirements in effect when it was built. Inspection services such as the Ball Time Service also applied rules that differed between railroads.
Dollar watches
The NAWCC’s entry on dollar watches describes them as very inexpensive, non-jeweled, mass-produced watches. They did not necessarily sell for exactly a dollar. Their parts were stamped from sheet metal rather than machined, and they were not designed to be serviced. The entry notes that the Ingersoll brothers became involved in dollar watches as an addition to their line of low-cost goods, that Ansonia announced a low-cost watch in early 1894, that Ingersoll bought the Trenton Watch Company in 1908, and that the Waterbury Clock Company, which had been making Ingersoll’s watches, purchased Ingersoll in March 1922.
Other categories you may see
Pocket watches were also sold through jewelers and retail catalogs, with different movement grades and case metals such as gold, gold-filled, silver and base metal. Case decoration, such as engraved scenes, does not by itself indicate the quality of the movement inside. Wristwatches gradually replaced pocket watches during the 20th century.
How to identify one
- Open the case back and look for the maker’s name, model or grade, serial number and jewel count on the movement.
- Note the case markings and metal. Do not assume a case is solid gold or silver without confirmation from a jeweler or appraiser.
- Compare the serial number with published maker references, or ask collector organizations such as the NAWCC.
- Photograph the dial, movement and case, since good photos help when asking collectors or appraisers for opinions.
Condition and value
Value depends on the maker, grade, rarity, originality, condition of the dial and case, and whether the movement runs reliably. Replaced parts and later dials usually affect collectors’ interest. Prices vary widely, so use a written appraisal for insurance or sale rather than a figure from a listing.
Caring for a pocket watch
The Canadian Conservation Institute states that the small, delicate mechanisms in watches can go wrong very easily and are difficult to mend, and it does not recommend treatment strategies for owners because they require specialized tools and skills. Its storage advice is to keep watches in a safe place that is dry, with a steady temperature and free of dust, to avoid vibration and to handle them with care, wrapped in acid-free paper inside a strong, stable box. Seek a watchmaker with experience in antique movements if a watch needs work.
Photo: “Waltham Riverside 19j Hunter.jpg” by Majvdl, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. An American Waltham hunter-case pocket watch; it is not a watch offered for sale here.
Discover more from Antique Stuff
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
