A love token is an ordinary coin that was taken out of circulation, smoothed on one or both sides and engraved with initials, names, dates or a picture as a keepsake. The history here draws on the Smithsonian National Museum of American History, a Collectors Weekly feature with the National Valentine Collectors Association’s Nancy Rosin and the Love Token Society’s Sid Gale, the Royal Mint and the Token Corresponding Society.

What makes a coin a love token
The Smithsonian describes love tokens as coins altered after minting: makers smoothed away the original design and then hand-engraved or pin-punched initials, dates, pictures and messages. Pin-punching uses a sharp point and hammer to build up a design from small dots. The result was a personal object that could be worn as a charm, a pendant or part of a bracelet, or simply kept as a memento.
Collectors Weekly adds that the coins were sanded or scraped flat on at least one side, and that love tokens can be found all over the world.
Early traditions: benders, treizains and pin-punching
The practice has older roots. The Royal Mint explains that in England, love tokens were commonly made from silver coins bent by hand. Collectors call these “benders,” and metal detectorists often find them. It was the sixpence, the Mint says, that took the starring role. Collectors Weekly adds that men carried coins for luck and bent them in opposite directions to distinguish them from other pocket change.
Collectors Weekly also describes a French custom from the late sixteenth century, in which 13 specially carved coins called treizains were given to a young couple at their wedding. Around the late 1600s or early 1700s, it reports, ordinary people in Britain learned to make their own designs by pin-punching. The first English coins that were truly engraved used simple scrimshaw-like lines for names and dates marking births, weddings, anniversaries and deaths, and were usually made from copper coins such as halfpennies and pennies.
Convicts, sailors and keepsakes of parting
Some of the best-researched engraved coins came from separation. The Token Corresponding Society describes two series that have been studied in depth. The first are transportation tokens, often engraved or pricked out with a nail on worn or smoothed cartwheel pennies of George III from 1797, made by prisoners held on the hulks before transportation. The second are coins engraved with ships or allusions to ships, probably given to loved ones before dangerous voyages.
Collectors Weekly mentions “prisoner tokens” with inscriptions such as “When this you see, remember me.” The society notes that most engraved coins, once parted from their recipients, lost their meaning, because initials alone rarely identify anyone.
The Victorian peak
According to Collectors Weekly, love tokens reached their height of popularity in the United States and Great Britain in the late 1800s. The article links that to the period’s sentimentality: by 1865 nearly everyone in the United States had lost someone in the Civil War, and in Britain, Queen Victoria’s romance with Prince Albert, and her mourning after his death in 1861, made it fashionable to wear jewellery that revealed the contents of the heart.
Typical designs included forget-me-nots, an arrow piercing two hearts, and names such as the “Nellie” on a dime from a pocket-watch chain, which the article illustrates. The Smithsonian’s collection includes tokens engraved with initials and a relationship, such as one inscribed “Your brother,” and the museum notes that several tokens were sometimes grouped into a brooch.
Dating and identifying a token
A love token has two dates: the date on the coin and the date of the engraving. The two can be decades apart, because a worn coin might have been engraved long after it was minted. The Smithsonian notes that dating is difficult for exactly this reason. Coin dates give only the earliest possible date for the token, so the style of lettering and the engraving technique, and the form of the jewellery, are considered alongside them.
- Smoothing: one side, or both, is smoothed to give a flat field.
- Engraving or pin-punching: pin-punched designs are made of dots, while engraved designs show continuous lines.
- Content: initials, a name, a date, a symbol such as clasped hands or two hearts, or a short verse.
- Coin type: silver coins such as sixpences and shillings were widely used in Britain, while copper coins were used for many early engraved pieces.
- Mounting: loops, pins, bracelets and chains show how a token was worn.
Collecting and care
Love tokens attract collectors of coins, jewellery and social history. According to the Token Corresponding Society, a great many pieces are known and almost all are unique in design, with workmanship ranging from the simplest scratching on a smoothed coin to masterpieces of the engraver’s art. Researching the name, the place and the coin type can sometimes give a token a story, as with the ship-related and transportation tokens studied by specialists. The museum collections cited here are good places to compare designs.
Top image: “19th CENTURY LOVE TOKEN ENGRAVED ON 1841 THALER a – Flickr – woody1778a” by Jerry “Woody” from Edmonton, Canada, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Discover more from Antique Stuff
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
